Why Do Contractors Choose Workyard Over When I Work?

Precise time tracking, task-based scheduling, detailed job costing, compliance rules, and more — Workyard has the tools you need to manage your mobile workforce with ease!

Try Workyard Free

I’m grateful for the time we’ve saved and the stress of payroll has become so much lighter for us. We can attribute that to Workyard.

Dana Almaraz Director, Allied Restoration

We’re a service company and crews may have 5-12 jobs a day. With the GPS tool I can let customers know ETAs in real-time.

Ian Cota Owner, Ic Electric

Easy to use. One step for employees. Easy for me to process payroll and monitor hours on the fly.

Shaun Telford President, Telford Heating

Weekly time spent on payroll and job allocation went from four hours weekly to less than one hour

Kathi Smith Vice President, D&S Electric

I like that I can instantly run a report in Workyard to show me how we’re doing across any of the five projects we’ve got running at the same time.

Kristi Miller Owner, Eric Miller Electric

Workyard will save me $2,500 in inflated payroll costs from 1 guy alone. Guys would round to a 7 am arrival time. Now I can see 7:18, 7:14 actual arrival times on site.

Dan Hausmann Owner, American Craftsman Contracting

With Workyard, I have insight into exactly what is getting done. Everything is dated and timestamped, so there’s no contest about it.

Bill Kapaldo President, Construction Punch Services

Workyard allows me to really consolidate time. I’ve saved a lot of time routing people by proximity and best case scenario situations. I’ve never been able to do that before.

Shiloh Hoggard IT Business Relationship Manager, Accord Group

We’ve had at least a solid six weeks now with all of our guys fully on the app, and in six weeks, we actually over exceeded that $150,000 that we had originally estimated for an entire year.

April Callaway Administrative Assistant to the CEO, AV Decking

Workyard vs. When I Work

Looking for the right features and functionality to manage a busy team of contractors? Check out what Workyard offers to see how it stacks up against When I Work!

When I Work logo
Time Tracking
Real-time GPS
Mileage tracking
Rule-based geofencing
Auto clock-in and clock-out
Offline tracking and logging
Time card location tagging
Worker/admin notes on time cards
Downloadable time card reports
GPS breadcrumb trails for worker travel
Facial / biometric clock-in
Manual supervisor clock-ins
Worker Scheduling
Integrated visual calendar
Real-time worker availability
Task/job checklists
Live map view of active workers
Drag-and-drop schedule editing
Bulk schedule updates
Repeatable/recurring tasks
Dispatch route optimization
Downloadable task/project reports
Job and Cost Tracking
Customizable cost codes
Project-based cost tracking
Automatic site visit capture
Project cost tracking by employee
Mileage costing
Worker task updates (files + notes)
Centralized team communications
Real-time project management (updates, reassignments, etc.)
Automated customizable project rules
Receipt tracking
Labor Law Compliance
Meal and rest break reminders
Auto-add/insert meal and rest breaks
Automatic overtime adjustments
Customizable overtime and break rules
Auto-clock rules based on geofencing settings
Location-specific (CA, WA, etc.) break and OT settings
User Experience + Customer Support
Detailed user onboarding
Easy/quick new-user walkthroughs
Intuitive modern interface
User permission settings (user, admin, etc.)
User and team groups (by division, project, etc.)
Manager time card editing and approval
Admin controls via mobile app
Multilingual support
U.S. based customer support team
Detailed self-serve knowledge base
Integrations
QuickBooks (Desktop/Online)
ADP (Workforce Now, Run, etc.)
Sage (50, 100, 300, etc.)
Foundation Software
Gusto
Rippling
Paychex
Paycor
Paylocity
ComputerEase
Oracle NetSuite
Developer API
Export to PDF or CSV (Excel, GSheets, etc.)
Pricing
Base cost
$50 / mo.
N/A
User cost
$6+ / mo. / user
$3+ / mo. / user
Offers?
Offer details
Annual plan saves up to 24%
Discounted rate of $6.65/mo. per user (billed annually)
Free trial?
Trial details
14 days (no CC needed)
14 days (no credit card required)

Find out why over 50,000 pros trust Workyard for workforce management.

See how it works

How Workyard Compares (User Scores)

Scores from real users on Capterra, the iOS App Store, and the Google Play Store.

When I Work logo
User Reviews
Ease of Use
4.8
4.5
Customer Service
5.0
4.4
Features
4.7
4.3
Value for Price
4.8
4.4
Overall (Capterra) Score
4.9
4.5
iOS Score
4.3
4.8
Android Score
4.2
4.9

Why Choose Workyard?

For construction professionals weighing their options between Workyard and When I Work, choosing Workyard offers distinct advantages tailored specifically to the construction industry’s unique needs. Here’s why Workyard stands out as the more suitable choice for construction labor management:

Enhanced Feature Set for Construction Needs

Workyard is designed with a deep understanding of the construction sector’s requirements. It provides specific features like mileage tracking, automatic site visit capture, project cost tracking by employee, mileage costing, and receipt tracking—functions not available in When I Work. These features help streamline complex projects and ensure accurate job costing, which are critical for efficient management and cost control in construction projects.

Superior Time Tracking Capabilities

Workyard offers robust time-tracking capabilities, including real-time GPS, offline tracking, and auto clock-in and clock-out features. This functionality is vital for construction sites where accurate time logging directly impacts project timelines and labor costs. When I Work lacks several of these key features, such as offline tracking and auto clock-in, which might limit its utility in remote or demanding construction environments.

Customizable for Construction Regulations and Requirements

Workyard supports customizable overtime and break rules, automatic overtime adjustments, and location-specific settings for different states like California and Washington. This compliance aspect is crucial for construction businesses that need to adhere to various regional labor laws to avoid legal issues and ensure workforce satisfaction.

Robust Integration Options

Workyard integrates seamlessly with major payroll and accounting software like QuickBooks, ADP, and Sage, which are often used within the construction industry. This integration capacity extends to Foundation Software and Oracle NetSuite, making it more adaptable to existing workflows in construction firms. When I Work offers some integrations but lacks compatibility with key platforms like Sage and Oracle NetSuite, which could be a deal-breaker for firms relying on these systems.

Tailored Pricing and High Customer Satisfaction

Workyard offers competitive pricing with clear benefits for annual subscriptions, which can lead to significant savings. It also boasts high user satisfaction ratings, especially in customer service and ease of use, indicating a strong alignment with user needs and seamless onboarding—factors that enhance daily operational efficiency.

By focusing on features that directly address the pain points of construction management, such as comprehensive job cost tracking and advanced GPS capabilities for on-site accountability, Workyard provides a more aligned solution for construction professionals seeking efficient, scalable, and compliant workforce management tools.

For firms aiming to optimize operational efficiency and project oversight, Workyard presents a compelling option over When I Work.

Want to see more detailed coverage of When I Work? Click the link in this sentence to check out our No-Nonsense Review of When I Work, which includes a detailed analysis of the app’s features, advantages, shortcomings, pricing, user reviews, alternatives, and more!

Workyard’s job tracking software supports construction HR payroll officer tasks with features tailored for construction and trades ex. property management teams. Link to payroll systems like QuickBooks, Paycor, Paylocity, Rippling, and Gusto for error-free synchronization.


See more head-to-heads: Workyard vs Contractor Foreman, Workyard vs Housecall Pro, Workyard vs Homebase, Workyard vs Connecteam, and Workyard vs Workiz.

View More View Less

What Workyard Offers

Workforce management built for the field — trusted by over 50,000 construction and field service pros across the U.S.

GPS Time Clock

The most accurate GPS time clock app for construction and field services. Easy to use for workers, with the accuracy and detail leaders and admins need. Track every minute from every worker and save thousands in avoidable payroll waste and time fraud.

See how it works
contractors-and-field-service-person

Worker Scheduling

Scheduling software designed for contractors — eliminate the pain of manual scheduling with a digital team calendar that helps you organize jobs and communicate to your employees exactly what needs to be done with checklists, photos and more.

See how it works

Job Tracking

Job tracking software designed for contractors — easily keep track of your resources, time, costs and profitability on every job. Enjoy seamless workflow management and insightful reporting.

See how it works

Job Costing

Live & accurate construction cost tracking — construction cost tracking software that automatically captures project labor costs with every time card. Empower key personnel with the insights they need with powerful dashboards and reporting.

See how it works

Labor Compliance

Labor compliance software that protects your business — simplify labor compliance in with one powerful platform built for contractors. Ensure simplified and automated compliance to federal, state, and local labor regulations.

See how it works

Detailed reporting and analytics

Get key details from your time & project data — the key insights you need to run your business better, with customizable reports and dashboards.

See how it works

Find out why over 50,000 pros trust Workyard for workforce management.

See how it works